Comparison of academic performance with a traditional textbook versus a digital openly-licensed textbook

Authors

  • Thomas A. Clobes California State University Channel Islands
  • J. Jacob Jenkins
  • Hannah Haid
  • Rebecca Allen

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.55420/2693.9193.v13.n1.63

Keywords:

digital textbook, openly-licensed resources, traditional textbook, Hispanic-Serving Institution, academic performance

Abstract

With the utilization of open educational resources (OER) and digital materials becoming more popular, research is needed to determine if academic outcomes are affected with the increasing shift to digital content. The goal of this research was to analyze the academic performance of students using a traditional physical textbook, as compared to those using an electronic copy of a similar textbook provided free through the campus library. The traditional and digital no-cost textbook comparisons were made between two sections of the same upper division undergraduate course taught at Hispanic-Serving Institution. The two sections of the course were taught during the Fall 2019 semester, both online, with the same faculty member facilitating both sections. There was no statistical difference in mean discussion grades, t(62)=-0.714, p=0.478, d=0.178444, mean written assignment grades, t(62)=-1.985, p=0.053, d=0.49613, and  mean quiz grades, t(62)=-1.711, p=0.092, d=0.427858. However, when looking at the overall total course grade, the mean no-cost course was statistically higher than the traditional textbook course, t(62)=-2.097, p=0.042, d=0.524348. Instructors do not need to be concerned about student outcomes with the increasing implementation of such materials. Universities providing free digital access to textbooks can help address financial concerns for these students without sacrificing academic performance.

Metrics

Metrics Loading ...

References

Allen, G., Guzman-Alvarez, A., Molinaro, M., & Larsen, D. (2015). Assessing the impact and

efficacy of the open-access ChemWiki textbook project [PDF document]. Educause

Learning Initiative Brief. Retrieved from https://net.educause.edu/ir/library/pdf/elib1501.pdf.

Ariyo, O., & Reams-Johnson, A. (2021). Destroying the Textbook Tower: Analysis of OER. In

Enhancing Higher Education Accessibility Through Open Education and Prior Learning

(pp. 53-66). IGI Global.

Baker, R. S., Lindrum, D., Lindrum, M. J., & Perkowski, D. (2015). Analyzing early at-risk

factors in higher education elearning courses. Proceedings of the 8th International

Conference on Educational Data Mining. Retrieved from

http://www.columbia.edu/~rsb2162/2015paper41.pdf

Boling, B. W., & Kohn, K. (2019). Textbooks are expensive, but OER can be challenging:

Providing e-textbook access through the library. Proceedings of the Charleston Library

Conference. https://doi.org/10.5703/1288284317037

Chulkov, D. V., & Vanalstine, J. (2013). College student choice among electronic and printed

textbook options. Journal of Education for Business, 88(4), 216–222.

doi:10.1080/08832323.2012.672936

Choppin, J., Carson, C., Borys, Z., Cerosaletti, C., & Gillis, R. (2014). A typology for analyzing

digital curricula in mathematics education [PDF document]. International Journal of

Education in Mathematics, Science and Technology, 2(1), 11-25. Retrieved from

https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1066359.pdf

Clinton, V., & Khan, S. (2019). Efficacy of open textbook adoption on learning performance and

course withdrawal rates: a meta-analysis. AERA Open, 5(3), 1–20.

doi:10.1177/2332858419872212

Covarrubias, R., & Fryberg, S. A. (2015). Movin’ on up (to college): First-generation college

students’ experiences with family achievement guilt. Cultural Diversity & Ethnic

Minority Psychology, 21, 420-429. doi:10.1037/a0037844

Covarrubias, R., Valle, I., Laiduc, G., & Azmita, M. (2019). “You never become fully

independent”: Family roles and independence in first-generation college students.

Journal of Adolescent Research, 34(4): 381–410.

https://doi.org/10.1177/0743558418788402

Denis, J., Donadio, A., & Klein, K. (2015). The Environmental Impact of Growing Numbers of

E-books in Libraries [PDF document]. Retrieved from

https://www.bc.edu/content/dam/files/schools/cas_sites/envstudies/pdf/Student

Research/2015 project paper/paper-2.pdf.

deNoyelles, A., & Raible, J. (2017). Exploring the Use of E-Textbooks in Higher Education: A

Multiyear Study. Retrieved from https://er.educause.edu/articles/2017/10/exploring-the-

use-of-e-textbooks-in-higher-eduation-a-multiyear-study.

Environmental Protection Agency. (2014). Greenhouse Gas Emissions from a Typical Passenger

Vehicle [PDF document]. (EPA-420-F-14-040). Washington, DC: Office of

Transportation and Air Quality.

Ermis-Demirtas, H., Watson, J. C., Karaman, M. A., Freeman, P., Kumaran, A., Haktanir, A., &

Streeter, A. M. (2018). Psychometric properties of the multidimensional scale of

perceived social support within Hispanic college students. Hispanic Journal of

Behavioral Sciences, 40(4), 472-485.

Feldstein, A., Martin, M., Hudson, A., Warren, K., Hilton, J., & Wiley, D. (2012). Open

textbooks and increased student access and outcomes. European Journal of Open,

Distance and E-Learning, 16(57). Retrieved from https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ992490

Fischer, L., Hilton, J., Robinson, T. J., & Wiley, D. A. (2015). A multi-institutional study of the

impact of open textbook adoption on the learning outcomes of post-secondary students.

Journal of Computing in Higher Education, 27(3), 159–172. doi:10.1007/s12528-015-

-x

Hilton, J. (2016). Open educational resources and college textbook choices: a review of research

on efficacy and perceptions. Educational Technology Research and Development, 64(4),

–590. doi: 10.1007/s11423-016-9434-9

Hilton, J., Gaudet, D., Clark, P., Robinson, J., & Wiley, D. (2013). The adoption of open

educational resources by one community college math department. The International

Review of Research in Open and Distributed Learning, 14(4), 37–50.

doi:10.19173/irrodl.v14i4.1523

Jenkins, J. J., Sánchez, L. A., Schraedley, M. A., Hannans, J., Navick, N., & Young, J. (2020).

Textbook broke: Textbook affordability as a social justice issue. Journal of Interactive

Media in Education, 1(3), 1.

Mangen, A., Walgermo, B. R., & Brønnick, K. (2013). Reading linear texts on paper versus

computer screen: Effects on reading comprehension. International Journal of

Educational Research, 58, 61-68. doi:10.1016/j.ijer.2012.12.002

Millar, M., & Schrier, T. (2015). Digital or printed textbooks: which do students prefer and why?

Journal of Teaching in Travel & Tourism, 15(2), 166–185.

doi:10.1080/15313220.2015.1026474

Montalto, C. P., Phillips, E. L., McDaniel, A., & Baker, A. R. (2019). College student financial

wellness: Student loans and beyond. Journal of Family and Economic Issues, 40(1), 3-21.

Nicholas, D., Rowlands, I., & Jamali, H. R. (2010). E-textbook use, information seeking

behaviour and its impact: Case study business and management. Journal of Information

Science, 36(2), 263–280.

doi: 10.1177/0165551510363660

Pawlyshyn, N., Braddlee, Casper, L., & Miller, H. (2013). Adopting OER: A Case Study of

Cross-Institutional Collaboration and Innovation. Retrieved from

https://er.educause.edu/articles/2013/11/adopting-oer-a-case-study-of-crossinstitutio

nal-collaboration-and-innovation.

Rodríguez Amaya, L., Betancourt, T., Collins, K. H., Hinojosa, O., & Corona, C. (2018).

Undergraduate research experiences: Mentoring, awareness, and perceptions—A case

study at a Hispanic-serving institution. International Journal of STEM Education, 5(1), 1-

Weisberg, M. (2011). Student attitudes and behaviors towards digital textbooks. Publishing

Research Quarterly, 27(2), 188-196. doi:10.1007/s12109-011-9217-4

Winitzky-Stephens, J., & Pickavance, J. (2017). Open education resources and student learning

outcomes: a multilevel analysis. International Review of Research in Open and Distance

Learning, 18(4), p. 35-49.

Xu, G. F., & Guo, J. X. (2018). Improving library user experience: Wi-Fi network assessment.

Journal of Library Administration, 58(8), 806–834.

https://doi.org/10.1080/01930826.2018.1516948

Downloads

Published

2022-11-28

How to Cite

Clobes, T., Jenkins, J. J., Haid, H., & Allen, R. (2022). Comparison of academic performance with a traditional textbook versus a digital openly-licensed textbook. HETS Online Journal, 13(1), 52-74. https://doi.org/10.55420/2693.9193.v13.n1.63

Issue

Section

Articles